Monday, February 06, 2012

Florida Rock Development Reboots, Meets Resistance

With demolition of the concrete plant finally complete, RiverFront on the Anacostia, the on-again off-again Southeast waterfront mega-project is on, again - pending various hearings, presentations, meetings, and ultimate approval of some very substantial changes to the zoning application.
Developers Patriot Transportation Holding Inc. and Midatlantic Realty Partners LLC (MRP) filed a modification with the Zoning Commission last month to, among other things, modify the Phase One building from an office complex to a residential building. The proposed residential building would be nine stories tall and include up to 350 units, 286 underground parking spaces, and 300,000 square feet of gross floor area (8% of which would be set aside for affordable housing at 80% of AMI). The new filing retains the 12,500 s.f. of retail space for lease, but now wants to earmark 7,000 s.f. as "flex space" or "residential amenity space."

Last week, the Zoning Commission gave their first impressions of the new plans, and it wasn't pretty. One commissioner called it "an affront" and a "bastardization," even going so far as to suggest the developers might have to start the PUD process from square one. Another excoriated the developers from reducing the initial 80,000 s.f. of retail space to under 24,000 s.f. in the latest filing, with 7,000 of that possibly being converted to non-retail "flex space." Even the most positive board member damned the project with faint praise - characterizing it as an improvement on the original PUD, but "boring" and "simplistic." In the end, the board deferred a decision, and the next public hearing is on February 13.
The new building, designed by SK&I, is U-shaped, facing the river, with a private inner courtyard. On the east side is a planned greenspace (Anacostia Plaza) and on the west side, in between the Phase One building and the Phase Two (also residential) building, another large plaza (the Mews) that "privileges pedestrians over vehicles." The new landscape plan, by Oculus, uses the idea of "ecotone" (in the report, this is defined as "an ecological term referring to the transitional zone between two ecologies") to create an impressive stormwater management and filtration system that will both provide lush public native plant green spaces, and filter runoff. (And the Anacostia River can use all the help it can get.)

Phases II (a 262K s.f., 130-foot tall residential building), III (326K s.f., 130-foot tall office building), and IV (275K s.f., 130-foot tall hotel) are unchanged. FRP anticipates a Q2 2013 groundbreaking, with move-ins starting in Q1 2015, and everything wrapped up by that summer.
Big picture, the plan is cut from the same cloth as the plans for the Wharf and the Maryland Avenue redevelopments. (There are only so many ways to skin a cat, after all.) Much like those plans, this latest filing is hoping that their conversion of the Phase One building from office to residential "will provide the critical mass of people necessary in order to support future office and retail uses." Of course, this could take a while, which is the thinking behind the "flex space." What if they build it, but people don't come? The plan also asks for permission to use the Phase II/III/IV sites for interim projects like a farmer's market or temporary retail, rather than letting those spaces remain dormant. It's a good strategy to lure more people to the area, and can only help not just their development, but the neighborhood as a whole as it gears up to make the transition to world-class waterfront. But first, developers need to win over the Zoning Commission, which is proving to be a harder task than they may have anticipated. 


Payton on Feb 6, 2012, 2:08:00 PM said...

That's a shame. Residential doesn't offer the same density that office does (i.e., 1000 sq. ft. houses two residents or four office workers), and having more residents on site will make it more difficult to lease the remaining retail to livelier, noisier uses (e.g., bars) that might be appropriate next to a ballpark.

That said, it probably makes sense given the distance to Metro and the surfeit of empty offices nearby. Plus, there's only so many little retail nodes facing the waterfront that can be developed in isolation -- this site is far enough from the Yards Park that they won't be seen as one contiguous "restaurant row."

Anonymous said...

There needs to be a mix of offices and residence. If an area is all businesses, then it gets a bunch of lunch places, banks and dry cleaners and rolls up after 5pm and on weekends.

If its all residences, it's dead during the day.

With both you can have a wider variety of business and the area can bustle day, evening and weekends.

Anonymous said...

One worries about yet another large rental building in the Ballpark District, sized for a REIT to buy at top dollar and therefore charge top dollar rents for, ensuring turnover and denying much sense of place or "neighborhood" in a meaningful sense of the word. Reduction in the retail component only compounds the problem.

For a by-right project, this concern isn't relevant, but Florida Rock is a PUD. A PUD should have public amenities. The "ecotone" possibly counts, as would the park. But the percentage of affordable/subsidized units seems to be the same as IZ requires for a by-right development, and such a large building ensures that it will be more a world unto itself than part of an organically urban community.

John on Feb 7, 2012, 10:21:00 AM said...

An ecotone is a transition between two ecosystems or habitats. The phrasing used in this article makes no sense (there is no such thing as "an ecology", so you can't have a "transition zone between two ecologies").

Post a Comment

Commercial ads will be deleted, so don't even think about it.


DCmud - The Urban Real Estate Digest of Washington DC Copyright © 2008 Black Brown Pop Template by Ipiet's Blogger Template